Martha Stewart Living patio furniture was once a staple at major retailers, offering affordable, stylish outdoor sets with coordinating cushions. But if you own one of these sets, you’ve probably noticed: the cushions are discontinued, and finding exact replacements is nearly impossible. The fabric fades, the foam compresses, and suddenly you’re stuck with a structurally sound frame and nowhere to buy the original cushions. This guide walks through your options, from hunting down secondhand matches to commissioning custom replacements and even refurbishing what you have.

Why Martha Stewart Patio Cushions Were Discontinued

Martha Stewart Living outdoor furniture was sold primarily through Home Depot and Kmart, with manufacturing and distribution handled by third-party licensees. When those retail partnerships ended or shifted, the furniture lines were phased out. Home Depot stopped carrying most Martha Stewart outdoor collections around 2020, and Kmart’s bankruptcy drastically reduced inventory availability.

Once a furniture line is discontinued, replacement parts, especially soft goods like cushions, are the first to disappear. Cushions wear out faster than frames, but they’re expensive to warehouse and don’t generate ongoing revenue for retailers. Manufacturers don’t typically stockpile replacement cushions for discontinued lines, so when inventory sells out, it’s gone.

This isn’t unique to Martha Stewart. It’s a common issue across midrange patio furniture brands sold through big-box stores. The frames often outlast the product support, leaving homeowners hunting for aftermarket solutions.

How to Identify Your Martha Stewart Cushion Model

Before you start searching for replacements, you need accurate measurements and model information. Start by checking the underside of the cushion or the furniture frame itself. Some sets have tags or labels with model numbers, collection names, or SKU codes. If the tag is faded or missing, search your email or credit card statements for the original purchase, Home Depot order confirmations often include full product names.

Next, measure your cushions carefully:

• Length and width at the widest points (measure in inches, to the nearest half-inch)
• Thickness of the cushion at its center (most patio cushions range from 3 to 5 inches)
• Shape details: square corners vs. rounded, tied backs vs. sewn, boxed edges vs. knife edges
• Tie or attachment style: fabric ties, elastic straps, or Velcro loops

Take clear photos from multiple angles, including close-ups of ties and corner construction. These details matter when ordering custom replacements or searching secondhand listings. Note the fabric pattern and dominant colors, Martha Stewart lines often had names like “Charlottetown,” “Palm Cove,” or “Living Majorca.” Matching the collection name helps narrow online searches.

Where to Find Replacement Cushions for Discontinued Sets

Finding exact-match cushions for discontinued sets requires patience and creative searching. Start with Home Depot’s website: use the search function with your model name or SKU. Occasionally, clearance stock or returned items reappear in limited quantities. Check back weekly, as inventory fluctuates.

Call your local Home Depot store and ask to speak with the outdoor furniture department. Some stores have old floor models, damaged box returns, or forgotten stock in clearance sections. Be specific with your model name and measurements. If one store doesn’t have inventory, ask them to check nearby locations.

Martha Stewart’s website occasionally references licensed product lines. While they don’t sell replacement cushions directly, their product archives sometimes list original manufacturing partners or suggest authorized retailers.

Reach out to outdoor furniture specialty stores in your area. Some independent retailers bought closeout inventory when major lines were discontinued and may have cushions in back stock. Bring your measurements and photos.

Online Marketplaces and Secondhand Options

eBay is the most reliable source for discontinued cushions. Search using your collection name plus “cushions” or “replacement.” Set up saved searches with email alerts, new listings appear regularly as people sell off old sets. Check the condition carefully: look for terms like “new with tags,” “light fading,” or “stored indoors.”

Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist often have sellers parting out patio sets. Search broadly (“Martha Stewart patio,” “outdoor cushions”) and filter by location to avoid high shipping costs. Cushions are bulky, so local pickup saves money.

OfferUp and Nextdoor work similarly. Post a “wanted” ad with your model details and measurements. Neighbors who are replacing their sets may sell you their old cushions cheap.

Check estate sales and Habitat for Humanity ReStores. These locations frequently carry outdoor furniture donations, and cushions are often separated from frames. Bring a tape measure and your photos.

Custom Cushion Solutions That Fit Martha Stewart Frames

If secondhand searches fail, custom cushions are the most reliable option. Several companies specialize in made-to-order outdoor cushions using your exact measurements. Expect to pay $60–$150 per seat cushion and $80–$200 per back cushion, depending on fabric grade and foam density.

Cushion Source, Foam Factory, and Cushion Comfort all offer online configurators. You input dimensions, select foam thickness (4-inch is standard for seating: 3-inch works for back cushions), choose fabric (Sunbrella is the industry standard for UV and mildew resistance), and specify tie placements. Most companies provide fabric swatches by mail before you commit.

Sunbrella fabric costs more upfront but lasts 5–10 years outdoors without major fading. Cheaper polyester blends fade within 2–3 seasons. For foam, ask for high-density polyurethane wrapped in Dacron batting. This prevents the lumpy, collapsed feel that happens with cheap foam. Some makers offer quick-dry foam cores, which shed water faster, worth it if your cushions get rained on frequently.

Bring your measurements to a local upholstery shop. Many can fabricate cushions for less than online companies, especially if you’re ordering a full set. Ask to see samples of their outdoor work and inquire about marine-grade zippers and thread, standard upholstery zippers corrode outdoors.

For outdoor living projects requiring a coordinated look, consider ordering a few extra yards of your chosen fabric to make throw pillows or recover seat cushions on nearby furniture. This creates visual continuity even if the new cushions don’t perfectly match the originals.

DIY Cushion Recovery and Refurbishment Projects

If your existing cushions have solid foam but worn fabric, recovering them is a straightforward DIY project. This works best for cushions without complex tufting or welting.

Materials:

• Outdoor fabric (Sunbrella or equivalent: calculate 1.5x the surface area of each cushion to allow for seams and overlap)
• Marine-grade zippers (length = perimeter of cushion minus 4 inches)
• UV-resistant outdoor thread
• Sewing machine capable of handling heavy fabric
• Fabric scissors, measuring tape, pins

Steps:

1. Remove old covers carefully. Use a seam ripper to open stitching along one side. Keep the old cover intact, it’s your pattern.
2. Press and measure the old fabric pieces flat. Note seam allowances (typically 1/2 inch).
3. Cut new fabric using the old cover as a template. Mark top and bottom clearly.
4. Sew box corners if your cushion is boxed (has a gusset running around the edge). Pin gusset strips to top and bottom panels, right sides together.
5. Install the zipper along the back edge of the gusset. Use a zipper foot attachment. Leave the zipper halfway open, you’ll need this to turn the cover right-side out.
6. Finish seams with a zigzag stitch or serger to prevent fraying. Outdoor fabric unravels quickly.
7. Turn right-side out, insert the foam, and zip closed.

Safety note: Use a heavy-duty needle (size 16 or 18) for your machine. Outdoor fabric can snap standard needles. Wear safety glasses, broken needles can fly.

If the foam is compressed or crumbling, replace it. Cut new foam to size using an electric carving knife or serrated bread knife. Foam Factory and Joann Fabrics sell outdoor foam by the sheet. Wrap the foam in a layer of Dacron batting before inserting it into the cover, this softens edges and prevents the fabric from catching on foam.

For porch projects that emphasize comfort and durability, consider adding a layer of waterproof ticking between the foam and outer fabric. This extends foam life significantly in humid climates.

Budget-Friendly Alternatives to Original Cushions

If custom cushions exceed your budget, generic replacement cushions from big-box stores can work as stopgaps. Measure carefully and look for “universal fit” cushions in standard sizes: 18×18 inches, 20×20 inches, or 24×24 inches for seats, and 22×22 inches or 24×24 inches for backs.

Walmart, Target, and Wayfair carry budget lines in the $20–$40 per cushion range. These typically use thinner foam (2–3 inches) and lower-grade polyester fabric that fades within one or two seasons, but they’ll get you through a summer while you save for better options.

Discount closeout stores like TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Big Lots often stock overstocked or previous-season cushions at 40–60% off retail. Inventory is unpredictable, so check frequently.

Another option: outdoor cushion storage bags and covers. If your existing cushions have fading or minor staining but the structure is intact, a water-resistant cover ($15–$30 per cushion) can extend their life another season or two. These slip over the existing cushion and usually have a zipper closure. They won’t fix compressed foam, but they hide cosmetic damage.

For tight budgets, consider seat cushions only. Many people find that replacing just the seat cushions, and leaving the backs bare or using small throw pillows, cuts costs in half while still improving comfort. Metal or resin frames are often fine to sit against without padding.

Finally, if you’re replacing an entire set and the frames are worn too, it may be time to invest in new furniture with better parts availability. Look for brands that sell replacement cushions separately and openly list model numbers. POLYWOOD, Tropitone, and Brown Jordan all offer long-term parts support, though at higher price points than Martha Stewart Living originally commanded. For multi-year outdoor furniture planning, parts availability is worth considering upfront.